rose thorn @ 2010-08-20T11: 08:00
a nice Friday, I wish!
Allow me, that I immediately jump into cold water, unfortunately I just RBIN etws time today.
be warned, dispassion about the dire situation, I suppose you document does not. Unless, of course, scientific Evidence (or lack thereof) you are no matter as such, but then again you what is in the number of abused from you brethren. One can also believe in God and his brave unmoved while fully aware that he can die in Pakistan people. This seems to go, although I do not understand it. How can you represent a medical therapy, in which not succeed for 200 years of proof of effectiveness will? So I had long since given up and I wanted something else ...;)
I know that under homeopathic fans a great religious war for the "true homeopathy is. Since there are extremely esoteric currents, which in turn some neatly with the pseudo-scientific group batteln. Me is the same since then error is error even if they are still erring argue with each other. On the political level, I care about most is homöopathsiche practical reality, and at the theoretical level rather construct the faith and the historical sources. And since it is unfortunately not in all areas very bright in terms of logical thinking. The above-I sure showed up a bit flippant pseudo-logic of homeopathy in curing hemorrhoids is no joke, but mainstream and is also in the "Organon" by analogy to describe Sun
"Similia similibus curentur" means that exactly those substances allegedly cure a defect that call this infirmity in high doses produced. This is the way of interesting conclusions about the nature of some of Hahnemann's experiments, but we can now better ...;) In any event, I, after him, heart rhythm disturbances alleviate this by I give the patient an agent that would trigger a high dose of heart rhythm disturbances. Infections are often treated in that-usually-entzündugsfördernde substances such as the poison of the honey bee, mercury or arsenic (arsenic does not cause internal inflammation, but the symptoms of the virus have a similar effect, which is probably in the 18th century, not be administered as different characters). This idea is completely absurd, especially because he was transferred to the whole of nature. And it also explains why there are noticeable in the Arzneimittelllisten of Homeopaths many poisons and disease-causing substances. My impression is: Hahnemann, the principle of similarity in ignorance of the true laws of nature arbitrarily defined as the natural law and then to remain "trials" held up had the remedies that would fit in his opinion, in this framework.
And now for the second nonsense of potentiation.
Since the people with such nice gifts such as mercury or arsenic that would die off like flies, of course, it was thought to a cheap trick out: The more I dilute a remedy, the stronger it works. Hm hmmmmmm. That leads to the absurd situation that of all the drugs are supposed to be most effective, which contain the active ingredient is no longer out of sheer dilution. This illogic was the people at some point even clearer, so they came up with the next excuse: the water memory! Huhuuuu ...
by the esoteric doctrine of disembodied "information" that the water is noted with a "water memory", is explained to the patient's stupid smart, why can not help him and he should pay for NOTHING. For the existence of water memory There are of course much meaning neither explanation nor even a hint of slip. It is simply asserted, as always. Too bad, because if there were such a thing, one would have for long been able to collect the Nobel Prize. The irony of the matter is this: Of all the tangible science must bow to the Homöos if they want to harm anyone. You must dilute it takes so long until the drug according to the teachings of classical chemistry is not potent enough to take on a larger scale connections and interact. Hats off to the cleverness with which this bug is sold as a feature!
legitimate questions, which nullify this illogic is regeläßig aus dem Weg gegangen:
Warum ist Leitungswasser kein extrem wirksames homöopathisches Mittel? Jemand im Internet hat korrekt festgestellt: „Jedes Glas Wasser kommt an vielen Substanzen vorbei „. Da denke ich mir doch sogleich: Sind nicht alle Stoffe dieser Welt in massiver Verdünnungspotenz im Wasserkreislauf vorhanden? Die gleiche Frage kann man für Regenwasser, den Bodensee – ach, eigentlich für jedes größere freie Wasser stellen. Ist es nicht lebensgefährlich, im Unterrein Wasser zu schöpfen, wo doch im Oberrhein eine Tollkirsche (Belladonna) hineingefallen sein könnte? Homöopathie pur!
Und wenn homöopathische Mittel umso stärker wirken, je verdünnter they are: why I can not be missed by the non-use (diluted will not do so) a dose? The thing with the contamination is still unclear. is the chemically pure substance is not perfect, a homeopath is always a small percentage of impurities in its remedies. If he is so busy potentiated to himself, then, logically, it potentiated the effect of the impurities with the same. And as impurities in the starting material but (hopefully) had the lower compartment, the potentiation should also draw more here! How this contradiction is explained?
And if water has such a great memory: Why will remember only the water dilution of Homeopaths, and not what it had previously behind? All H2O, we have, there is here since the birth of our planet. Every drop of water, either as a physical unit or in various chemical compounds, already billions of years in this world and this was likely involved in trillions of dilution processes. What is it, where are these "information" that would need to be ultra-strong yet, the longer their supply by diluting her is? Forget about everything? Water suffers from amnesia when it gets into the hands of homeopaths? And if so, what is the little bit of shaking Hahnemannche to 4.5 billion years forming, Enrichment, solution, distillation and dilution?
Ridiculous! Wen homeopaths were right would be, every drop of water dangerous.
Well, as Hahnemann postulated his work, did not know how much about the water cycle and even reasonably educated people such as Buffon (The geology was to understand the end of the 18th century still in the future) estimate the age of the earth to a maximum of 75,000 years.
Fortunately, the world is in fact more complex, great and exciting.
I will now first for a while can not answer, I now turn in Leipzig a music video and then cut this night after night and has to work. Therefore, I would like to re the champions of the diluted Le (h) (e) to this point like to have the last word.
What ever you think out there, I wish you a great weekend! ;)
0 comments:
Post a Comment